Working hour: Monday – Friday/8AM – 5PM

|

Email: contact@mcac.vn

|

Hotline: (+84) 935 925 068 - 0236 3656799

| Language:

Điện thoại: (+84) 935 925 068

Language:

APPLICATION OF EQUITY IN DISPUTE RESOLUTION THROUGH COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION

17/11/2026

In international commercial arbitration, certain legal frameworks permit an arbitral tribunal to decide disputes on the basis of equity where the parties have expressly authorised it to do so. In Vietnam, the application of equity must be considered within the framework of the applicable law. This article examines the concept, legal basis and limitations of applying equity in commercial arbitration and highlights certain considerations for parties to disputes and arbitral tribunals

 

1. THE CONCEPT OF EQUITY IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION

Decision on the basis of equity (ex aequo et bono) is a mechanism that allows an arbitral tribunal to decide the merits of a dispute according to what it considers fair and reasonable, within the limits permitted by law and the authority conferred by the parties. International arbitration instruments often refer to this mechanism alongside the power to act as amiable compositeur.[1] In both cases, the arbitral tribunal decides the merits of the dispute by issuing an award.

Under Vietnamese law, Article 45(3) of the 2015 Civil Procedure Code (CPC) defines equity in the context of the courts' resolution of civil matters where no statutory provision is applicable. Equity is based on socially recognised principles of justice and ensures humanity, impartiality and equality in the rights and obligations of the parties to the civil matter.[2]

2. LEGAL BASIS AND CONDITIONS FOR THE APPLICATION OF EQUITY

2.1. Model Law and international arbitration rules

Article 28(3) of the 1985 UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (as amended in 2006) provides that an arbitral tribunal may decide ex aequo et bono or as amiable compositeur only if the parties have expressly authorised it to do so.[3] Article 35(2) of the 2021 UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules imposes the same requirement. Article 22(3) of the 2026 Arbitration Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) requires the parties to agree to confer such authority on the arbitral tribunal.[4] The UNCITRAL Model Law serves as a reference for States when developing their arbitration legislation.

2.2. Vietnamese law

In Vietnam, the 2010 Law on Commercial Arbitration, as amended and supplemented in 2025 (LCA), does not specifically provide for the ex aequo et bono mechanism. Under Article 14 of the LCA, the arbitral tribunal applies Vietnamese law to disputes without a foreign element. For disputes involving a foreign element, the arbitral tribunal applies the law chosen by the parties. In the absence of such a choice, the arbitral tribunal applies the law it considers most appropriate. Where Vietnamese law or the law chosen by the parties contains no specific provision governing the merits of the dispute, Article 14(3) permits the arbitral tribunal to apply international customs, provided that their application or the consequences thereof are not contrary to the fundamental principles of Vietnamese law. Article 24(1) and (2) of the Rules of Arbitration of the Middle Commercial Arbitration Center (MCAC) contain corresponding provisions on determining the applicable law.[5]

Where Vietnamese law governs the merits of a dispute, the relevant sector-specific legislation should be examined before considering the supplementary legal bases under the 2015 Civil Code. For matters falling within the scope of civil law, where the parties have no agreement, the law contains no applicable provision and no applicable custom exists, consideration should be given to applying the law by analogy. If the law cannot be applied by analogy either, Article 6(2) of the 2015 Civil Code provides for the application of the fundamental principles of civil law set out in Article 3, case law and equity.[6]

In an arbitration dispute, Article 6(2) of the 2015 Civil Code may be considered as a supplementary legal basis where Vietnamese law governs the matter to be decided and the above conditions are satisfied. For proceedings governed by the LCA, any agreement on the application of equity should be considered in light of Article 4(1) and (2), concerning respect for the parties' agreements and compliance with the law, and Article 14, concerning the applicable law.

2.3. Limitations to bear in mind

  • The parties should clearly define the scope of the authority conferred if they choose the ex aequo et bono mechanism. The power to decide under this mechanism must have a basis in the law governing the arbitral proceedings and in the authority conferred by the parties, even if the parties have not chosen the applicable law.
  • The arbitral tribunal must comply with mandatory legal provisions. When considering an application to set aside an award under Point (đ), Clause 2, Article 68 of the LCA, the court may set aside the award on this ground only if it determines that the award violates a fundamental principle of Vietnamese law relevant to the resolution of the dispute and seriously prejudices the interests of the State or the lawful rights and interests of one or more parties to the dispute or a third party.[7] With respect to foreign arbitral awards, Vietnamese courts refuse recognition if recognition and enforcement of the award in Vietnam would be contrary to the fundamental principles of Vietnamese law, pursuant to Point (b), Clause 2, Article 459 of the 2015 CPC.[8]
  • Under Article 28(4) of the UNCITRAL Model Law and Article 35(3) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules, the arbitral tribunal must decide the dispute in accordance with the terms of the contract, if any, and take into account the trade usages applicable to the transaction. This requirement also applies where the arbitral tribunal has been authorised to decide ex aequo et bono.
  • The award must state the grounds on which it is based pursuant to Point (đ), Clause 1, Article 61 of the LCA, unless the parties agree that no grounds need be stated. When setting out its grounds, the arbitral tribunal should identify the basis for invoking equity and explain how it has applied equity in deciding each relevant claim of the parties.

3. SIGNIFICANCE AND LIMITATIONS OF APPLYING EQUITY

Within the framework of Article 6 of the 2015 Civil Code, equity may help resolve matters not otherwise addressed in civil relationships. The ex aequo et bono mechanism allows an arbitral tribunal to take account of the particular circumstances of a transaction within the scope of its authority.

The flexibility of ex aequo et bono may make outcomes less predictable. Where the scope of authority or the assessment criteria are unclear, the outcome may depend to a greater extent on the arbitral tribunal's assessment of the circumstances of the case.

4. CONCLUSION

Applying equity in the resolution of disputes through commercial arbitration may help achieve fairness in individual cases, but it must be situated within the appropriate legal framework. An arbitral tribunal should clearly establish whether it is applying equity as a supplementary mechanism under the applicable law or exercising the authority conferred upon it to decide ex aequo et bono.

Parties considering the ex aequo et bono mechanism should examine the law governing the arbitration, the applicable arbitration rules and the law of the jurisdiction in which recognition and enforcement of the award may be sought. The agreement conferring authority must be clear, but cannot substitute for the legal basis for applying this mechanism.

 

[1] United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL), Explanatory Note on the Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration, para. 40.

[2] Article 45(3) of the Civil Procedure Code No. 92/2015/QH13 (Consolidated Document No. 21/VBHN-VPQH dated 12 February 2026).

[4] Article 35(2) and (3) of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules (2021 version). Article 22(3) of the 2026 ICC Arbitration Rules (effective from 1 June 2026).

[5] Article 14 of the Law on Commercial Arbitration No. 54/2010/QH12 dated 17 June 2010 (see Consolidated Document No. 60/VBHN-VPQH dated 15 August 2025). See also Article 24(1) and (2) of the MCAC Arbitration Rules.

[7] Point (đ), Clause 2, Article 68 of the LCA and Point (đ), Clause 2, Article 14 of Resolution No. 01/2014/NQ-HĐTP dated 20 March 2014.

[8] Point (b), Clause 2, Article 459 of the Civil Procedure Code No. 92/2015/QH13 (see Consolidated Document No. 21/VBHN-VPQH dated 12 February 2026).

Related news

PARTY AUTONOMY IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION: SCOPE AND LIMITS
19 11/2026

PARTY AUTONOMY IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION: SCOPE AND LIMITS

Party autonomy allows parties to determine the method and procedure for resolving their disputes through arbitration. However, this autonomy must be exercised within the limits of the law and the applicable arbitration rules.

DISPUTE RESOLUTION BY ARBITRATION: HOW IS BUSINESS INFORMATION KEPT CONFIDENTIAL?
11 11/2026

DISPUTE RESOLUTION BY ARBITRATION: HOW IS BUSINESS INFORMATION KEPT CONFIDENTIAL?

How is business information protected in commercial arbitration? Learn about the principle of confidentiality, arbitrators’ confidentiality obligations, and measures to protect trade secrets under Vietnam’s Law on Commercial Arbitration.

Contact with THE MIDDLE COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION CENTER